Vampires in the Mirror: Why Outrage Culture Never Sees Itself
Updated: 4 days ago

NOTE: This is a follow-up to my previous blog, "Pre-Wired for Outrage", and explores empty reflections, energy vampires, and why good intentions never erase real-world harm.
It is tempting to talk about "the algorithm" as though a rogue line of code in an algorithmic recommendation engine woke up one morning and invented bigotry, misogyny, or religious authoritarianism. It didn't. People hold the mirror. They hold it up expecting to see their own righteousness reflected back. But what happens when the mirror shows "nothing wrong here" precisely because the person holding it is operating far outside of normal human empathy? Technology simply decides when, to whom, how intensely, and how often to tilt that mirror in a favourable, flattering light for the user.
In my last post, I looked at how online digital systems amplify human grievance. Yet what fascinates—and troubles—me even more is what happens when the people who shaped that mirror look straight into it and see nothing at all. To understand why, we don't need a new political buzzword. We need an old Gothic warning: the vampire.
The Kind Face and the Empty Mirror
When we picture a vampire, we usually picture a cartoon monster—snarling, dramatic, obviously evil. That misses the real horror of the myth. The most unsettling detail in vampire folklore isn't the fangs; it is the empty mirror.
Picture instead a warm, neighbourly, respectable figure—someone who wears a cross around their neck, smiles kindly at the community potluck, and genuinely believes they are defending all that is decent. Yet when they hold a mirror up to their own face, the mirror stays completely blank. And around their collar, that cross is quietly beginning to smolder.
Why? In psychological counselling, there is a foundational principle we learn early on: the visceral impact of abuse is real whether it was intended or not. Motive is rarely the real issue; the abuse of others is the issue.
When a neighbour is wounded by scapegoating, exclusion, or spiritual coercion, the harm lands in their body and their life regardless of how pious or sincere the sender felt. Yet in our present outrage-driven public square, we get trapped endlessly debating motive: "Did they really mean to be cruel? Aren't their intentions pure? Are they just protecting their heritage?"
Like vampires standing before a mirror, movements steeped in control and certainty cannot, will not, and do not see themselves in that reflection—precisely because they have convinced themselves their motives are righteous. The moment we let them shift the conversation from the measurable impact on real people to the purity of their own intentions, the reflection vanishes from the mirror.
Four Rules of the Gothic Vampire Mythology That Carry Over to Digital Online Rage
Once you notice that blank mirror, the rest of the vampire mythology maps onto modern outrage culture—and Christian Nationalism (a.k.a Project 2025 and the New Apostolic Reform) in particular—with uncomfortable precision:
1. The Aversion to Daylight Vampires wither in direct sun because open light exposes everything. Closed ideological communities—whether a rigid pulpit or a hyper-curated social feed—survive by keeping the curtains drawn. Open history, diverse friendships, and Socratic questioning—that simple, irritating challenge of "Are you sure about that?"—act like direct sunlight on a worldview that can only survive in the dark. Even that ideological pallor is a choice: what happens when you never step outside the bunker into the sunlight of a wider, varied humanity.
2. The Energy Vampire A vampire has no life force of its own; it has to drain vitality from living hosts. If you want to see how that feeding works in daily civic life, think of Colin Robinson—the "energy vampire" from the TV series What We Do in the Shadows. He doesn't lurk in a castle hunting for blood; he stands under fluorescent lights in mundane rooms, draining the vitality out of ordinary people through circular grievances, pedantic traps, and exhausting bad-faith arguments.
That is an uncanny portrait of contemporary outrage politics. It doesn't always defeat compassionate, constructive policies in a single dramatic strike—it drains them. By turning basic human empathy, public education, healthcare, or pluralistic kindness into endless, bad-faith culture-war trench warfare, it siphons the civic energy right out of communities—leaving citizens hollowed out, cynical, pale, and gaunt shadows of their former vibrant selves.
3. The Threshold In folklore, a vampire cannot cross your doorstep unless someone inside invites it in. That is the exact bargain of the attention economy (the click/like/share/subscribe media). The feed packages fury as righteous self-defence, and every time we click, share, or nod along in tribal validation, we unlock the deadbolt and invite that mindset straight into our living rooms.
4. The Smoldering Cross Here lies the deepest irony. When religious nationalism fuses faith with political domination—treating empathy, humility, and care for the vulnerable as "weakness"—it turns the very symbols it claims to defend against itself. Strip away the power fantasy, and the actual ethic of the old rugged cross—self-giving love, standing with the marginalized, refusing the sword—sits against the collar like a quiet burn, reminding us that cruelty in God’s name is still cruelty.
Stepping Out of Enclosed Spaces and into the Light of Understanding
Twenty-four hundred years ago, Socrates walked the Athenian agora irritating his fellow citizens by puncturing absolute certainty in broad daylight. Today, we live inside machines engineered to reward certainty and punish doubt.
We don't have to live in the mental enclosures of our own choosing. Stepping into the sunlight doesn't require having every metaphysical answer figured out—whether you walk through the world with faith or without it. It begins the moment we refuse to hide behind good intentions when real people are being hurt, look honestly at the reflection in the mirror, and step outside where our actual neighbours live.
Want to dig deeper into the psychology and history behind this post? Two accessible, rigorously researched books cover much of this terrain:
Jonathan Haidt, The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion: A readable, deeply researched look at why human reason acts less like an impartial judge and more like a defence attorney for our tribal instincts—explaining why certainty blinds us to our own reflection.
Kristin Kobes Du Mez, Jesus and John Wayne: How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation: A compelling historical account of how religious nationalism replaced empathy and humility with militant dominance, turning sacred symbols against their own foundational ethic.




Comments